Contents

Products applied to the lash line to lengthen, thicken or darken lashes. This is the most legally troubled category in the whole cosmetics catalogue: the ingredients that actually work are drugs, and several of the products sold as cosmetics contain them anyway.

The three tiers

Tier What is in it Status Does it work?
Prescription Bimatoprost 0.03% (Latisse) FDA-approved drug Yes — approved for hypotrichosis of the eyelashes on trial evidence
Cosmetic serums containing prostaglandin analogues Isopropyl cloprostenate, dechloro-dihydroxy-difluoro ethylcloprostenolamide, and similar Unapproved new drugs in FDA's view Yes — with the same side effects
Genuine cosmetic conditioners Peptides, panthenol, biotin, castor oil, amino acids Cosmetic Conditioning and appearance at best; no reliable growth

How the prostaglandin analogues work

Bimatoprost is a prostaglandin analogue developed for glaucoma. Longer, thicker, darker lashes turned up as a side effect in glaucoma patients, and the lash indication followed. The mechanism is an extension of the anagen (growth) phase of the lash cycle and an increase in the number of follicles in it.

It works, and the side effects come from the same mechanism:

  • Permanent iris darkening — brown pigment increasing in blue, green or hazel irises. This is the one that does not reverse.
  • Eyelid skin darkening, which usually does reverse on stopping.
  • Periorbital fat atrophy — a hollowed, sunken look around the eye, reported with prostaglandin analogues and slow to recover.
  • Redness, itching, dry eye.
  • Loss of the gained lashes within weeks of stopping. It is a maintenance drug.

The regulatory position, stated plainly

FDA has issued warning letters to companies marketing lash serums containing isopropyl cloprostenate and related prostaglandin analogues, on the basis that a product intended to affect the structure or function of the body is a drug under FD&C Act sec. 201(g) — and, having no approved application, is an unapproved new drug and also misbranded.

The consumer-facing summary: a cosmetic that genuinely grows lashes is, by definition, making a drug claim. If it works the way it says, it is not a cosmetic. If it is a cosmetic, it conditions.

Products have been reformulated and renamed repeatedly in response to enforcement, so the presence or absence of a prostaglandin analogue is best checked by reading the ingredient list for anything ending in -prost, -prostenate or -prostenolamide.

What a genuine cosmetic serum can do

Condition the lash shaft so it looks glossier and breaks less; hydrate the lash line; and, with peptides, make an appearance claim that is difficult to disprove and difficult to demonstrate. Castor oil, the most common home remedy, has no controlled evidence for lash growth — and getting oil into the eye nightly is its own irritation.

What actually helps most lashes: stop over-curling, stop scrubbing off waterproof mascara, take breaks from extensions, and treat the underlying blepharitis if it is there. Lash loss can also be a medical sign — thyroid disease, alopecia areata, trichotillomania, chemotherapy — and is worth a clinician's opinion rather than a serum.

Where it sits in the rules

Cosmetic — FDA primary category (03) eye makeup preparations — only for genuine conditioners with appearance claims. Anything intended to grow lashes is a drug.

Under MoCRA the small-business exemption does not apply to eye-contact products, and serious adverse events must be reported to FDA within 15 business days — which is how iris and periorbital effects from cosmetic-marketed serums become visible.

In the EU, prostaglandin analogues intended to affect lash growth are similarly treated as falling outside the Cosmetics Regulation, and several have been the subject of national market withdrawals.

Shelf life

Six months after opening for a wand or brush applicator that returns to the tube after touching the lash line. Stop at the first sign of eye irritation, redness, darkening or discomfort and see a clinician — and in this category, do that promptly, because two of the possible effects do not fully reverse.